A propane tankless water heater uses 0.8–2.5 gallons of propane per day for a typical family, costing $2.20–$7.50 per day at the 2026 national average of $2.80 per gallon. That translates to 200–500 gallons per year and $560–$1,400 annually, depending on household size, groundwater temperature, and unit efficiency.
The good news: a propane tankless uses 15–30% less propane than a standard propane tank heater because it eliminates standby losses and operates at higher efficiency (0.93 UEF vs 0.58–0.67 UEF for tank models).
The Propane Usage Formula
Propane contains 91,500 BTU per gallon. A tankless water heater's propane consumption follows this formula:
Gallons per day = (GPM x Minutes of use x Temperature rise x 500) / (91,500 x UEF)
Where GPM is the average flow rate during use, minutes of use is total daily hot water runtime, temperature rise is desired temp minus incoming groundwater, 500 is the constant (BTU to heat 1 gallon of water 1F per hour), and UEF is the unit's efficiency rating.
Simplified Version
For practical estimation:
Gallons per day = Daily hot water gallons x Temperature rise / (91,500 x UEF)
A family of 4 using 60 gallons of hot water per day with a 65F temperature rise and a 0.93 UEF condensing unit:
60 x 65 x 8.33 / (91,500 x 0.93) = 60 x 65 / (91,500 x 0.93 / 8.33) = approximately 1.27 gallons per day or 38 gallons per month.
At $2.80/gallon: $3.56/day, $107/month, $1,283/year.
Propane Usage by Household Size
Monthly and Annual Cost by Propane Price
Propane prices vary dramatically by region and season. Here is what a family of 4 (65 gallons/day, moderate climate) pays at different propane prices:
Propane price seasonality: Prices can swing 40–60% between summer lows and winter peaks. Lock in a pre-buy or fixed-rate contract in late summer (July–September) to avoid winter price spikes. A 500-gallon pre-buy in August at $2.20/gallon versus emergency delivery in January at $4.00/gallon saves $900 on the same 500 gallons.
Propane Tankless vs Propane Tank: Usage Comparison
Propane users see the biggest savings from going tankless because propane is expensive and standby losses on tank heaters waste 80–120 gallons per year — that is $225–$335 in pure waste at $2.80/gallon.
The payback on a propane tankless is often faster than for natural gas. A $2,000 premium over a propane tank, with $530–$870 in annual savings, pays back in 2.3–3.8 years.
Propane Tank Sizing for Tankless Heaters
Your propane storage tank must deliver adequate vaporization pressure to feed the tankless heater at full fire. This is critical — an undersized propane tank is the #1 cause of "my tankless keeps shutting off" complaints in propane homes.
Why cold climate matters for tank sizing: Propane vaporizes (converts from liquid to gas) more slowly in cold temperatures. A 250-gallon tank at 20F ambient can only deliver about 175,000 BTU/h of vaporized gas. At 0F, that drops to roughly 130,000 BTU/h. If your tankless needs 199,000 BTU/h, the 250-gallon tank cannot keep up in winter, even if it is full.
Rule of thumb: In cold climates (winter ambient below 20F), your propane tank should be rated for at least 150% of your tankless unit's BTU/h demand. For a 199,000 BTU/h unit, that means a 500-gallon tank minimum. Consult your propane supplier for a vaporization analysis specific to your location.
Reducing Propane Consumption
1. Choose a Condensing Unit
The efficiency gap between condensing (0.93 UEF) and non-condensing (0.82 UEF) is even more significant with propane. At $2.80/gallon, upgrading from non-condensing to condensing saves $130–$200/year — paying for the condensing premium in 2–4 years.
2. Lower Your Set Temperature
Reducing from 120F to 115F cuts propane usage by approximately 7%. For a family of 4, that is 25–35 gallons/year saved ($70–$100).
3. Install Low-Flow Fixtures
A 1.5 GPM showerhead instead of 2.0 GPM reduces hot water usage (and propane) by 25% per shower. Annual savings: 50–80 gallons ($140–$225).
4. Insulate Hot Water Pipes
Foam pipe insulation on the first 6 feet of hot and cold water pipe from the heater reduces heat loss in transit, meaning you run the faucet for less time before hot water arrives. Annual savings: 10–20 gallons.
5. Fix Leaks Immediately
A dripping hot water faucet wastes 1,660 gallons of hot water per year — approximately 8 gallons of propane per year ($22). A running toilet with a stuck hot valve wastes far more.
Real-World Propane Usage Data
Example 1: Rural Vermont — Family of 3
Setup: 1,800 sq ft home, 2 bathrooms. Rinnai RU160iP condensing (160,000 BTU/h). 500-gallon propane tank. Groundwater: 44F winter, 52F summer.
Measured usage: Winter months: 48 gallons/month. Summer months: 28 gallons/month. Annual: 425 gallons. At $3.20/gallon (Vermont avg): $1,360/year. Previous propane tank heater used 590 gallons. Annual savings: 165 gallons ($528).
Example 2: Rural Georgia — Family of 5
Setup: 2,600 sq ft, 3 bathrooms. Navien NPE-2 240S (LP version). 500-gallon propane tank. Groundwater: 60F winter, 72F summer.
Measured usage: Winter: 38 gallons/month. Summer: 22 gallons/month. Annual: 340 gallons. At $2.50/gallon: $850/year. Previous tank: 520 gallons ($1,300). Annual savings: 180 gallons ($450).
Example 3: Mountain Cabin — Seasonal Use
Setup: 1,100 sq ft cabin, occupied 120 days/year. Rinnai V53DeP (120,000 BTU/h non-condensing). 250-gallon tank. Groundwater: 48F.
Measured usage: Occupied months: 25 gallons/month. Empty months: 0 gallons. Annual: 100 gallons. At $3.00/gallon: $300/year. Previous tank: 300 gallons ($900) — standby pilot and losses ran all year. Annual savings: 200 gallons ($600). Payback on the $1,200 tankless premium: 2.0 years.
Key Takeaways
- Typical usage: 200–500 gallons/year ($560–$1,400 at $2.80/gal) for a family of 2–5
- Savings vs propane tank: 28–31% (130–290 gallons/year), worth $365–$810 annually
- Propane tankless has the fastest payback of any fuel type due to high propane costs — typically 2–4 years
- Tank sizing is critical — a 500-gallon tank is the minimum for 199K BTU units in cold climates
- Lock in pre-buy propane contracts in summer to avoid 40–60% winter price spikes
- Condensing saves an extra $130–$200/year over non-condensing on propane
- Seasonal homes see the largest savings — zero consumption during empty months
Related Articles
Hot Water Recirculating Pumps Explained (+ How They Work With Tankless)
KEEP+ • 12 min read
Smallest Tankless Water Heaters in 2026 (Compact Gas + Electric)
TRANSFORM • 13 min read
Tankless Water Heater Breaker Size Calculator (2026 NEC Guide)
KEEP+ • 11 min read
Tankless Water Heater Wire Size Calculator (AWG Guide for 2026)
KEEP+ • 11 min read